Funding opportunity

Funding opportunity: BBSRC-DFG Lead Agency Pilot 2023-2024

Submit an expression of interest for UK-Germany collaborations on the topic of Integrative Microbiome.

Your project should:

  • outline the proposed research aims and address the relevance of the work to integrative microbiome
  • provide a clear rationale behind the need for the UK-Germany collaboration and the choice of lead agency
  • provide cost and staffing full time equivalent (FTE) estimates

Full stage proposals will be a single joint proposal assessed by a lead agency, BBSRC or Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG). If successful, BBSRC will fund the UK component of your proposal and DFG will support the German component.

Projects can be up to three years in duration.

Stage one applications will be reviewed on a rolling basis. We encourage early submission.

Who can apply

Before applying for funding, check the following:

Who is eligible to apply

Standard eligibility criteria apply to this funding opportunity, applicants in the UK must meet the BBSRC eligibility requirements.

Institutions and researchers normally eligible for our funding include, but are not limited to:

  • higher education institutions (HEIs)
  • research council institutes (RCIs)
  • approved independent research organisations (IROs)
  • public sector research establishments (PSREs)

Applicants in Germany must meet the eligibility requirements of DFGs Individual Research Grants Programme (DFG form 50.01, PDF, 132KB).

Who is not eligible to apply

Applicants not based in either the UK or Germany are not eligible to apply.

Applications must include a UK and a German project lead

Equality, diversity and inclusion

We are committed to achieving equality of opportunity for all funding applicants. We encourage applications from a diverse range of researchers.

We support people to work in a way that suits their personal circumstances. This includes:

  • career breaks
  • support for people with caring responsibilities
  • flexible working
  • alternative working patterns

Find out more about equality, diversity and inclusion at UKRI and BBSRC’s equality, diversity and inclusion action policy.

What we're looking for

Scope

The aim of this programme is to support complementary research between UK and German research teams that will advance the mechanistic understanding of interactions between complex microbial communities.

Integrative microbiome

This joint DFG-BBSRC funding opportunity invites collaborative research proposals which aim to answer fundamental functional questions related to how phenomena mediated by microbiomes operate.

Integrative microbiome is a research area that seeks to combine investigation of complex communities of microorganisms (bacteria, fungi, archaea, protists and viruses) with their relationship and influence on environments with that of their relationship and influence on the environments with which they are associated. It examines the microbiome as a whole and considers the functional interconnections between microbial, host and wider environmental factors.

Key challenge

One of the biggest challenges in the integrative microbiome field is to move beyond correlative or associative studies to investigate the functional mechanisms underpinning these interactions. This includes how the constituents of microbial communities interact with each other, how the environment affects microbial population dynamics, and how the microbiome influences its host and vice versa.

The principal aim of applications to this funding opportunity should be the generation of new fundamental knowledge related to the function of the integrated microbiome. Through building joint UK-German capability and capacity in integrative microbiome research, BBSRC and DFG ultimately expect to establish the fundamental knowledge and evidence needed to enable scientifically robust management and utilization of these complex microbial communities in a range of contexts in the longer term.

Approach

Applications might be expected to take a range of complementary approaches and multidisciplinary proposals are encouraged. This includes proposals that are integrated across scales ranging from community ecology, organismal physiology, tissue, single-cell and molecular level interactions.

In addition to fundamental research in laboratory model systems, applications in areas involving microbiomes associated with non-human animals including livestock and companion animals, plants including crops, soil or other human-managed ecosystems (for example, greenhouses, aquaculture facilities.) are encouraged.

New tools and technologies now enable the functional dissection of integrative microbiome interactions at an unprecedented level of detail and generating vast amounts of quantitative data. For this reason, the development or adaptation of existing technologies or analysis approaches including bioinformatics and mathematical modelling will be supported, providing this can be expected to result in the underpinnings that answer the fundamental bioscience questions posed within the project.

Proposals which are only associative or correlative in nature and do not have a clearly articulated plan to dissect the functional underpinnings of any microbiome-associated effects will be excluded.

Examples of key challenges

Examples of key challenges are:

  • probing the role of variation and heterogeneity in microbiomes, within and between individuals (for example, single-cell, microfluidics)
  • establishing artificial ‘minimal’ microbiomes as experimental models in the laboratory to test the effects of perturbations in a controlled context such as gnotobiotic systems, organoids, rhizoboxes, hydroponics
  • establishing artificial ‘minimal’ microbiomes as experimental models in the laboratory to test the effects of perturbations in a controlled context such as gnotobiotic systems, organoids, rhizoboxes, hydroponics
  • developing an understanding of the integrative microbiome in a dynamic context across a time series including longitudinally or intergenerationally, or both
  • understanding the physical structure of microbiomes and how this influences functional relationships

Duration

The duration of this award is up to three years.

Funding available

Your proposed project should be in line with the typical scale of resource supported by the two agencies’ funding mechanisms participating in this activity. This would involve a small number of investigators and associated postdoctoral researchers and assistants (or alternatively in the case of DFG PhD support). Large consortia with many d PDRA/PhD positions are beyond the scope of this funding activity.

The full economic cost (FEC) of your project, including the UK and German components, may not exceed £2 million. Further guidance on budgets may be provided in feedback at the Expression of Interest stage.

BBSRC will fund 80% of the FEC for the UK component.

DFG will support costs of the German component.

The lead agency funding opportunity does not represent new funding. Proposals will be assessed in competition with all others submitted to agency programs, and outcomes will be subject to both success in peer review and the availability of funds from both BBSRC and DFG.

Supporting skills and talent

We encourage you to follow the principles of the Concordat to Support the Career Development of Researchers and the Technician Commitment.

International collaboration

If your application includes international applicants, project partners or collaborators, visit Trusted Research for more information on effective international collaboration.

How to apply

Overview of the BBSRC-DFG Application process

The BBSRC-DFG funding opportunity is comprised of two mandatory stages.

Stage one is the expression of interest (EOI) stage

The stage one is being managed by BBSRC on behalf of both agencies.

You should complete the stage one application using UK Research and Innovation (UKRI) Funding Service. Your application should address the following:

  • outline the proposed research aims and address the relevance of the work to Integrative Microbiome
  • provide a clear rationale behind the need for a German-UK collaboration and the choice of lead agency
  • provide cost and staffing FTE estimates
  • project duration (up to three years)

The agencies reserve the right to change the lead agency and to inform you accordingly during stage one.

To indicate that the proposal is to be considered under the lead agency management plan, you must preface your project title with ‘BBSRC-DFG’.

The application must meet:

  • DFG eligibility and remit requirements see relevant DFG Review Boards
  • BBSRC eligibility and remit requirements (Responsive Mode)
  • scope of the funding opportunity

Participating DFG review boards are:

  • review board 202 Plant Sciences
  • review board 203 Zoology
  • review board 204 Microbiology, Virology and Immunology
  • review board 207 Agriculture, Forestry and Veterinary Medicine

Applications will be reviewed by both agencies on a rolling basis. We therefore strongly recommend you submit your application ahead of the deadline. You will receive an outcome within 15 working days of submission.

Stage two is the full stage

The full stage is only open to you if you have been invited to submit following stage one.

All information and documentation should be submitted to the lead funding agency either through the UKRI Funding Service or DFG’s elan. Submissions will be managed as follows:

  • proposals received via the Funding Service will be managed following our internal processes.
  • proposals received via DFG’s elan will be managed following DFG’s internal processes.

For the purposes of managing the administration of the lead agency, full stage applications will be shared between our staff and DFG staff through our secure extranet.

Where BBSRC is the lead agency, once the full application has been submitted to us the German partner associated with the project must submit a copy of the proposal to DFG via DFG’s elan within one week after the closing date of the full proposals’ submission. This is to ensure that, if successful, a grant can be awarded by DFG to the German partner.

Where DFG is the lead agency, once the full application has been submitted to DFG no further information is required by BBSRC prior to the funding decision. The UK partner will be required to submit a copy of the proposal via the Funding Service if the proposal is recommended for funding so that UKRI can award a grant to the UK partner.

If you are invited to submit a research proposal, you will do so in accordance with the proposal preparation requirements of the lead agency. Detailed guidance documents including any additional forms required by the non-lead agency will be provided with the invitation to submit a full application.

A separate and additional budget form will be provided to provide justification of resources requested by the non-lead agency where relevant.

The proposal will be submitted by established programme deadlines or target dates determined by the lead agency.

The proposal should include descriptions of:

  • the proposed research (in the UK and Germany)
  • how the research aligns to integrative microbiome
  • the rationale for a UK-German collaboration
  • the UK and German research team
  • the total resources for the joint project (that is, the funds requested from both the DFG and BBSRC)

To indicate that the proposal is to be considered under the lead agency management plan, you must preface your project title with ‘BBSRC-DFG’.

For projects involving human subjects or vertebrate animals, UK researchers must comply with UK requirements and German researchers must comply with German requirements. Researchers should consult our policies and DFG policies ahead of submission.

For UK applicants this includes but is not limited to UKRI’s policy on animal use in research. For German applicants this includes but is not limited to the Genetic Engineering Act and the Convention on Biological Diversity. If DFG is acting as partner agency (non-lead agency), a separate additional document must be provided to DFG with the relevant information (Chapter 4.1 Ethical or legal aspects of the project of DFG form 54.01).

For BBSRC, all full proposals must be submitted to BBSRC responsive mode 24RM1. We anticipate the full proposal closing date to be January 2024.

For DFG, all full proposals must be submitted to the specific board to ensure timely review for the 2024 fiscal year. The DFG board deadline will be confirmed via correspondence when the stage one applicant is successful.

We are running the funding opportunity on the new Funding Service. You cannot apply for this funding opportunity on the Joint Electronic Submissions (Je-S) system.

If you do not already have an account with the Funding Service, you will be able to create one by selecting the ‘start application’ button at the start of this page. Creating an account is a 2-minute process requiring you to verify your email address and set a password.

If you are a member of an organisation with a research office that we do not have contact details for, we will contact them to enable administrator access. This provides:

  • oversight of every Funding Service application opened on behalf of your organisation
  • the ability to review and submit applications

Research offices that have not already received an invitation to open an account should email support@funding-service.ukri.org

To find out more about the role of research office professionals in the application process, watch our research office webinars about the new Funding Service.

Submitting your stage one application

The project lead is responsible for completing the application process on the Funding Service, but we expect all team members and project partners to contribute to the application and should represent the proposed work of the entire consortia.

Only the lead research organisation can submit an application to UKRI.

To apply:

  1. Select ‘Start application’ near the beginning of this page.
  2. Confirm you are the project lead.
  3. Sign in or create a Funding Service account. To create an account, select your organisation, verify your email address, and set a password. If your organisation is not listed, email support@funding-service.ukri.org
  4. Answer questions directly in the text boxes. You can save your answers and come back to them or work offline and return to copy and paste your answers. All questions and assessment criteria are listed in the ‘How to apply’ section on this Funding finder page.
  5. Send the completed application to your research office for checking. They will return it to you if it needs editing.
  6. Your research office will submit the completed and checked application to UKRI.

Deadline

BBSRC must receive your stage one application by 10 October 2023 at 4:00pm UK time.

You will not be able to apply after this time.

Make sure you are aware of and follow any internal institutional deadlines.

Applications will be reviewed by both agencies on a rolling basis. We therefore strongly recommend you submit your application ahead of the deadline. Applications will receive an outcome within 15 working days of submission.

General text on processing personal data:

BBSRC, as part of UKRI, will need to collect some personal information to manage your funding service account and the registration of your funding applications.

We will handle personal data in line with UK data protection legislation and manage it securely. For more information, including how to exercise your rights, read our privacy notice.

We will need to share the application and any personal information that it contains with DFG so that they can participate in the assessment process.  For more information on how DFG uses personal information, visit DFG privacy notice.

Outcomes publication

We, will publish the outcomes of this funding opportunity at awarded research grants.

If your application is successful, some personal information will be published via the UKRI Gateway to Research.

UKRI Funding Service: section guidance

Summary

There is no need to provide a summary at this stage. Complete this field with N/A.

Word count: 2

UK Applicants

List the key members of your team and assign them roles from the following:

  • project lead (PL)
  • project co-lead (UK) (PcL)
  • project co-lead (international) (PcL (I))
  • specialist
  • grant manager
  • professional enabling staff
  • research and innovation associate
  • technician
  • visiting researcher
  • researcher co-lead

Only list one individual as project lead.

Section: Research area

Question: What three phrases best describe the science area, or areas, covered in your proposed research project?

Word count: 20

Section: Vision

Question: What are you hoping to achieve with your proposed work?

What the assessors are looking for in your response
  • What is the topic of research including the academic and where relevant wider context?
  • Is the proposal within the remit of our participating committees and DFG boards?
  • Does the application clearly address the Integrative Microbiome scope of the funding opportunity?

Word count: 250

Section: Approach

Question: What are the specific objectives and how will you deliver the project?

What the assessors are looking for in your response
  • are the objectives and methodology clearly described?
  • are the potential outputs and outcomes well defined?

Some flexibility in objectives is permitted at stage two, subject to approval by the two agencies.

A brief list of references may be provided but is not required. Any references will be included in the word count.

Word count: 250

Section: German applicants

Question: Please provide the following details of the German applicants on this application:

  • name
  • institute
  • job title
  • email address

Word count: 100

Section: Team capability

Question: What is the contribution of the UK and German teams?

What the assessors are looking for in your response
  • does the application clearly describe the role and the contributions of the UK and German teams?
  • are you eligible for BBSRC and DFG support?
  • Information on any other project partners or collaborators, including their role and contribution.

Your suggested choice of lead agency might be driven by factors such as:

  • where the majority of the work is to be undertaken, for example. based on FTE estimates for the team
  • background to the project, including prior work by you
  • expected leadership or contributions to the project by the partners

Please note detailed eligibility checks will not be undertaken by us or DFG at this stage. It is your responsibility to ensure your team members are eligible for support. Please contact the respective agencies if required.

Word count: 150

Section: Resources

Question: What are the overall cost and staffing FTE estimates for the UK and German components of the project?

What the assessors are looking for in your response
  • overall estimates for costings and staffing FTE
  • clear separation of UK and German costings, in GBP and EUR respectively
  • combined budget below maximum £1.6 million funder contribution
  • a detailed calculation and breakdown of resources is not required at this stage

For example:

UK team:

Total cost estimate 600,000 GBP FEC, 480,000 GBP research council contribution

0.2 FTE time, 1.0 FTE PDRA, 0.5 FTE technician

German team:

Total cost estimate 300,000 EUR DFG contribution

1.0 FTE PDRA or 1.0 FTE doctoral researcher

Total funder contribution estimate

740,000 GBP, 853,000 EUR (exchange rate 1.153)

Word count: 200

Section: Lead agency

Question: State the proposed lead agency.

What the assessors are looking for in your response

Identify the proposed lead agency, either BBSRC or DFG

Your suggested choice of lead agency might be driven by factors such as:

  • where the majority of the work is to be undertaken, for example. based on FTE estimates for the team
  • background to the project, including prior work by you
  • expected leadership or contributions to the project by the partners

Word count: 10

Section: Lead agency rationale

Question: What is the rationale behind the choice of BBSRC or DFG as the lead agency?

What the assessors are looking for in your response
  • is the rationale behind the choice of lead agency clearly articulated and well justified?
  • does the application mention a specific BBSRC committee or DFG board?

Word count: 150

How we will assess your application

Assessment process

We will assess your application using the following process.

Stage one is the expression of interest (EOI) stage.

Prior to submission of a full proposal, you will submit an initial EOI to BBSRC using the UKRI Funding Service.

BBSRC will securely share the received applications with DFG for eligibility checks, namely whether the proposed research fits within the agencies’ portfolio, the research scope of the funding opportunity and whether the proposed researchers and institutions meet the agencies’ funding eligibility requirements. The agencies reserve the right to change the lead agency proposed by you if deemed necessary. Applications will be reviewed by us and DFG programme managers. The applications will not undergo external peer review.

The application will also be used to gauge proposal pressure by programme and assist programmes with budget planning.

You will be advised by BBSRC on behalf of both agencies whether you are invited to submit a full submission. DFG will be copied in the communication in response to applications where the lead agency is proposed to be DFG. Feedback on your application will be provided within 15 working days of submission.

Stage two is the full stage.

Full proposals (both the UK and German components) will undergo a single peer review process lead by either BBSRC or DFG, depending on where the proposal is submitted.

Proposals will be reviewed in competition with other unsolicited proposals or with proposals received in response to a specific funding opportunity by the lead funding agency. That is, proposals submitted to the lead agency management plan agreement will not undergo a special review process.

Proposals will be reviewed in accordance with the lead agency’s review criteria. While not identical, DFG and BBSRC ask reviewers to evaluate the proposed project on both its scientific or intellectual merit as well as its broader or societal impacts.

The use of a rebuttal phase will depend on the processes of the lead agency. Where BBSRC is the lead agency, evaluation reports will be anonymously forwarded to you and you may respond briefly and only in case you wish to do so. Your responses will serve as extra information for the assessment panel.

After respective checking and preferably not later than one week before the assessment panel meeting, responses will be forwarded to all meeting participants. Where DFG is the lead agency, no rebuttal phase will be used.

Read the Guidance for applicants for more information on our assessment process.

When BBSRC is the lead agency, all proposals submitted will be assessed by the four Responsive Mode committees in the usual manner, and in competition with all other proposals submitted to responsive mode.

Full applications must be received through 24RM1 following an invitation from the application stage. You should indicate as normal which committee is likely to be best able to assess the work proposed.

When DFG is the lead agency, you are advised to read the description of the DFG merit review process for more information.

Funding decision

After the reviews are received, program directors from the lead and non-lead agencies will discuss the potential outcomes. Afterwards, the lead agency will use its usual internal procedures to determine whether a proposal will be awarded or declined.

In the case of:

  • DFG: funding recommendations from relevant DFG standing review boards are received by the DFG Joint Committee and the final decision is made by the DFG Joint Committee.
  • BBSRC: funding recommendations from panels are received by research council officers who, taking into account the availability of funds, will fund those proposals recommended for funding in the order identified by the panel.

You will be advised whether their proposal has been recommended for funding or will be declined by the lead funding agency. You will receive copies of the unattributed reviewers’ comments and, where applicable, a panel summary.

If you are the lead applicant, you will be expected to forward the decision to your partners abroad. Where DFG is the non-lead agency, DFG will only send a decision letter without comments to the applicants in its country

If a proposal is recommended for funding, the German organisation will be supported by DFG and the UK organisation will be supported by us. DFG staff and our staff will review budgets to ensure that there are no duplications in funding.

Should a proposal be declined for funding, researchers should refer to each participating agency’s individual resubmission policies. For the purpose of this pilot funding opportunity, should you wish to resubmit a proposal through a future stage one funding opportunity should indicate that your application is a re-submission and clearly outline the changes that have been made. The agencies reserve the right to reject an application that does not meet the resubmission criteria.

Because the participating organisations have different funding cycles, it is possible that some projects will have delayed start dates in order to wait until funds become available.

Principles of assessment

We support the San Francisco declaration on research assessment (DORA) and recognise the relationship between research assessment and research integrity.

Find out about the UKRI Principles of Assessment and Decision Making.

Sharing data with co-funders

We will need to share the application (including any personal information that it contains) with DFG so that they can participate in the assessment process.

For more information on how DFG uses personal information, visit DFG privacy notice.

We reserve the right to modify the assessment process as needed.

Stage 1 assessment criteria

Here is a sample set of expert review guidance. While the content is not the same as what is asked of you, it should directly reflect it.

What we are looking for

To note this is for the stage one, for stage two please refer to the lead agency (BBSRC or DFG) guidance and assessment criteria.

Section: Vision
  • what is the topic of research including the academic and where relevant wider context?
  • is the proposal within the remit of the participating BBSRC committees and DFG boards?
  • does the application clearly address the Integrative Microbiome scope of the funding opportunity?
Section: Approach
  • are the objectives and methodology clearly described?
  • are the potential outputs and outcomes well defined?
Section: Resources
  • overall estimates for costings and staffing FTE
  • clear separation of UK and German costings, in GBP and EUR respectively
  • combined budget below maximum £1.6 million funder contribution
Section: Team capability
  • does the application clearly describe the role and the contributions of the UK and German teams?
  • is the rationale behind the choice of lead agency clearly articulated and well justified?
  • does the application mention a specific BBSRC Committee or DFG Board?
  • are the applicants eligible for BBSRC and DFG support?
  • information on any other project partners or collaborators, including their role and contribution. 

Contact details

Get help with your application

If you have a question and the answers aren’t provided on this page.

IMPORTANT NOTE: The Helpdesk is committed to helping users of the UK Research and Innovation (UKRI) Funding Service as effectively and as quickly as possible. In order to manage cases at peak volume times, the Helpdesk will triage and prioritise those queries with an imminent opportunity deadline or a technical issue. Enquiries raised where information is available on the Funding Finder opportunity page and should be understood early in the application process (for example, regarding eligibility or content/remit of an opportunity) will not constitute a priority case and will be addressed as soon as possible.

Contact Details

For help and advice on costings and writing your proposal please contact your research office in the first instance, allowing sufficient time for your organisation’s submission process.

For questions related to this specific funding opportunity please contact the funding opportunity team at inca@bbsrc.ukri.org

Any queries regarding the system or the submission of applications through the UKRI Funding Service should be directed to the helpdesk.

Email: support@funding-service.ukri.org
Phone: 01793 547490

Our phone lines are open:

  • Monday to Thursday 8:30am to 5:00pm
  • Friday 8:30am to 4:30pm

To help us process queries quicker, we request that users highlight the council and opportunity name in the subject title of their email query, include the application reference number, and refrain from contacting more than one mailbox at a time.

You can also find information on submitting an application here: Improving your funding experience

If you have questions specific to the German component of your application, please contact: BBSRC-DFG-pilot@dfg.de

Sensitive information

If you or a core team member need to tell us something you wish to remain confidential, please contact: inca@bbsrc.ukri.org

Include in the subject line: [the funding opportunity title; sensitive information; your UKRI Funding Service application number].

Typical examples of confidential information include:

  • individual is unavailable until a certain date (for example due to parental leave)
  • declaration of interest
  • additional information about eligibility to apply that would not be appropriately shared in the ‘Applicant and team capability’ section
  • conflict of interest for UKRI to consider in reviewer or panel participant selection
  • the application is an invited resubmission

For information about how UKRI handles personal data, read UKRI’s privacy notice.

Additional info

Background

Memorandum of understanding

DFG and UKRI have signed a memorandum of understanding on research cooperation.

The memorandum of understanding provides an overarching framework to encourage collaboration between Germany and UK research communities and sets out the principles by which jointly supported activities might be developed.

The memorandum of understanding provides for a lead agency arrangement whereby proposals may be submitted to either DFG (through elan) or UKRI (through the UKRI Funding Service).

BBSRC Eligible Committees

  • Responsive Mode committees A-D

DFG Eligible Review Boards

  • Review Board 202 Plant Sciences
  • Review Board 203 Zoology
  • Review Board 204 Microbiology, Virology and Immunology
  • Review Board 207 Agriculture, Forestry and Veterinary Medicine

Award conditions and reporting requirements

DFG and BBSRC will clearly state in award notices and any related documents that awards resulting from this activity were made possible by the BBSRC-DFG lead agency funding opportunity.

You will be expected to comply with the award conditions and reporting requirements of the agencies from which you receive funding.

Researchers will be required to acknowledge both DFG and BBSRC in any reports or publications arising from the grant.

Requests for extensions will be considered by the funding agency using standard procedures.

Requests for changes to awards will be discussed with other involved funding agencies before a mutual decision is reached.

Evaluation

Projects will be monitored through standard BBSRC and DFG reporting processes. BBSRC-funded research outcomes are captured through the UKRI Gateway to Research. DFG provides information on funded projects via GEPRIS (unless you explicitly wish not to do so). DFG requires a final report to be submitted to DFG which would cover outputs of both the German and UK component of the project.

Supporting documents

UK partner budget proforma template (DOCX, 47KB)

German partner proforma template (DOCX, 41KB)

Updates

  • 27 October 2023
    Contact details updated
  • 28 July 2023
    UK partner budget proforma template updated in the 'Additional info' section.

This is the website for UKRI: our seven research councils, Research England and Innovate UK. Let us know if you have feedback or would like to help improve our online products and services.